Enjoy the combination of rich creme brulee and zesty orange flavors in this delicious Orange Custard Pie recipe with fresh orange juice and zest in the homemade custard filling with a crushed biscoff biscuit base.
Table of Contents
The tangy citrus perfectly blends with the silky smooth custard, creating an memorable dessert for special occasions, or simply because you want to create something different with fresh oranges you have lying around.
Ingredients and substitutions for Orange Custard Pie
- Biscoff biscuits: These lightly spiced biscuits make the perfect base for these bars. If you are unable to obtain them, a great substitute in equal measure would be digestive biscuits and add in ยฝ teaspoon ground ginger spice when making the base.
- Butter: Unsalted butter is used here, salted also works as a fine substitute; just leave out any salt suggested in the recipe.
- Cream: Heavy cream was used here as it naturally makes the custard thick, but you could subsitute with pouring cream that will thicken thanks to baking.
- Egg yolks: Adding structure and making our custard what it is, the creme brulee would not be the same without these.
- Sugar: The best sugar in the base is superfine or caster though you could half and half the sugar with light brown sugar and caster sugar. The topping is best with superfine or caster sugar for a nice sweet crunch without additional flavor in that caramel.
- Salt: The flavor powerhouse, just a little adds a depth to the pie that creates a well rounded flavor.
- Orange: Fresh orange juice and zest will give you the strongest infusion of flavor for a truly beautiful depth to your pie.
See recipe card for quantities.
How to make Orange Custard Pie:
Step 1: Crush those cookies: Crush or blend the cookies as finely as possible before adding in the melted butter.
Step 2: Press into the pie dish: Press the combined crushed cookie and melted butter into your pie dish and bake.
Step 3: Heat the cream: Alongside the orange zest.
Step 4: Make your custard: Whip the egg yolks with orange zest until thickened and then whisk in the warm cream.
Step 5: Pour in the orange juice: Finish the custard with your orange juice and combine. Pour into the crushed cookie base.
Step 6: Place in the oven in a larger tray: Add boiled water half way up the sides of your pie dish.
Step 7: Bake: Bake until lightly golden, then allow to chill completely.
Step 8: Finishing the top: Just prior to serving, sprinkle over the sugar and caramelize with a blow torch or grill until the sugar has dissolved.
Step 9: Serve: Tap to crack the top, slice and serve.
Variations
You can definitely change up the dish by changing the following:
Pumpkin - you could substitute the orange juice with pumpkin butter for a Fall take on this recipe, though I have not tried this and cannot recommend an amount to infuse into the pie.
Chocolate - Add cocoa powder mixed with water in place of the orange juice and zest here.
Tea infused - You could infuse the cream with your favorite tea like this creme brulee here.
FAQ's for the best Orange Custard Pie
Orange pie has a delightful balance of flavors. The creamy custard filling is full of orange flavors with the orange zest adding a refreshing twist. The caramelized sugar crust on top provides a crispy texture and a subtle caramel flavor that complements the creamy filling.
Biscoff cookies arenโt readily found everywhere, so if the best description I have for their flavor is a deep subtle gingerbread tone. If you want to make this and canโt access biscoff cookies in your area, I recommend using half ginger and half graham crackers or digestive cookies in the base.
Yes, you can definitely make orange pie ahead of time. In fact, it's often recommended to allow the pie to chill in the refrigerator for at least a few hours or overnight to set and enhance the flavors. This makes it a great dessert option for parties or gatherings, as you can prepare it in advance and have it ready to serve when needed. Just remember to caramelize the sugar crust within 2 hours of serving to maintain its crispness.
Whilst serving with a dollop of whipped cream or thick yogurt is great, this holds it's own without anything on the side.
Firstly, the water bath provides gentle and even heat distribution around the custard, ensuring that it bakes slowly and evenly. This helps prevent the outer edges of the custard from overcooking or curdling while the center remains undercooked.
Secondly, it acts as a buffer, insulating the custard from direct heat and reducing the risk of cracking during baking. The moist environment helps maintain a more consistent temperature, preventing sudden changes that could lead to cracks on the surface of the custard. Overall, a water bath helps to achieve a smooth and creamy texture throughout the custard
More Orange recipes you'll love
Orange Pie
Ingredients
Base
- 250 grams / 8.8 ounces biscoff biscuits, crushed
- 90 grams / 3.2 ounces butter melted
Orange filling
- 250 milliliters / 1 cup heavy cream
- ยผ teaspoon sea or kosher salt
- 6 grams / 1 tablespoons orange zest roughly chopped
- 55 grams / 3 large egg yolks room temperature
- 100 grams / ยฝ cup superfine/caster sugar
- 80 milliliters / โ cup orange juice
Instructions
Base
- Preheat the oven to 180C/350F.
- Place the crushed biscuits in a bowl and stir the melted butter through until the mixture resemble wet breadcrumbs.
- Spoon into your tart dish and press evenly into the base and edges of your dish.
- Bake in the oven for 12 minutes or until lightly matte in appearance.
Orange filling
- Meanwhile, place the heavy cream, salt and 1 teaspoon of the orange zest into saucepan on medium heat and simmer for 3 minutes.
- Remove from the heat and allow to cool for 5 minutes.
- Meanwhile, place the egg yolks, sugar and remaining orange zest in a separate bowl and whisk until the eggs are pale, thick and fluffy, approximately 1 minute.
- Slowly pour ยผ of the warm cream into the eggs, whisking to incorporate and heat the eggs slowly, continue with the remaining cream in stages until completely combined.
- Add the orange juice to the custard mixture and whisk to combine.
- Pour the orange custard into your tart shell, straining, if you prefer. Place the dish into a large baking tray.
- Boil water and pour the water โ up the sides of the tart dish into the large baking tray.
- Slide carefully into the oven and bake for 50 minutes or until it is lightly golden on top and only slightly jiggly in the center.
- Remove and allow to cool to room temperature.
- Place in the fridge for minimum 1 hour to chill.
- Remove when ready to serve and sprinkle a further 30 grams / 2 tablespoons sugar evenly over the top.
- Carefully caramelize the top either with a blowtorch or under the grill or broiler until bubbling and charred.
- Tap, slice and serve.
- Enjoy
Video
Notes
- Orange: Fresh orange juice and zest will give you the strongest infusion of flavor for a truly beautiful depth to your pie.
- Biscoff cookie base: Biscoff cookies arenโt readily found everywhere, so if the best description I have for their flavor is a deep subtle gingerbread tone. If you want to make this and canโt access biscoff cookies in your area, I recommend using half ginger and half graham crackers or digestive cookies in the base.
- Tart dish: A fluted tart dish makes for the traditional tart and is easy to work with. The size of the dish used for this Orange Pie recipe is 21.5 centimeters or 8.5 inches, a medium size.
- Great make ahead dessert: The pie needs to chill in the refrigerator for at least a few hours or overnight to set and enhance the flavors. Just remember to caramelize the sugar crust and serve within 2 hours to maintain its crispness.
- Serve with: Usually I'd recommend serving with a dollop of whipped cream or thick yogurt, but this holds it's own without anything on the side.
Nutrition
Subscribe to receive a free weekly newsletter using seasonal produce as well as exclusive content!
Made it and loved it?
If you have made this recipe, it would mean so much to leave a review below to help more people find this.
Leave a Reply